I’ve made no secret over the years that <I>Guitar Hero</I> has never impressed me. While there are some complaints I have towards the game mechanics itself, most of my dislike comes from the fact that the majority of the music that soundtracks those games is music I would never listen to outside of that game (honestly, have you ever seen me listen to SRV or Aerosmith on my own accord?).
<I>Rock Band</I>, however, is a game I would for sure be owning had I a next-gen system (especially since you can now buy the prepherials seperately).
Why?
For one, singing and/or pretending to play drums is something I’ve always found more entertaining than playing with a plastic guitar. More importantly though, <I>Rock Band</I> has a more diverse selection of material to choose from, and that most of it is songs I would actually listen to or, in several cases, already own in some form or fashion. It also doesn’t hurt that every song is based on the master recordings (no crappy cover versions with altered guitar parts!)
I bring all of this up now because the tracklist to <I>Rock Band 2</I> has been published. Here’s what’s going to be on the game:
AC/DC: “Let There Be Rock”
AFI: “Girl’s Gone Grey”
Alanis Morissette: “You Oughta Know”
Alice in Chains: “Man in the Box”
Allman Brothers: “Ramblin’ Man”
Avenged Sevenfold: “Almost Easy”
Bad Company: “Shooting Star”
Beastie Boys: “So Whatcha Want”
Beck: “E-Pro”
Bikini Kill: “Rebel Girl”
Billy Idol: “White Wedding Pt. I”
Blondie: “One Way or Another”
Bob Dylan: “Tangled Up in Blue”
Bon Jovi: “Livin’ on a Prayer”
Cheap Trick: “Hello There”
Devo: “Uncontrollable Urge”
Dinosaur Jr.: “Feel the Pain”
Disturbed: “Down with the Sickness”
Dream Theater: “Panic Attack”
Duran Duran: “Hungry Like the Wolf”
Elvis Costello: “Pump It Up”
Fleetwood Mac: “Go Your Own Way”
Foo Fighters: “Everlong”
Guns N’ Roses: “Shackler’s Revenge”
Interpol: “PDA”
Jane’s Addiction: “Mountain Song”
Jethro Tull: “Aqualung”
Jimmy Eat World: “The Middle”
Joan Jett: “Bad Reputation”
Journey: “Anyway You Want It”
Judas Priest: “Painkiller”
Kansas: “Carry On Wayward Son”
L7: “Pretend We’re Dead”
Lacuna Coil: “Our Truth”
Linkin Park: “One Step Closer”
Lit: “My Own Worst Enemy”
Lush: “De-Luxe”
Mastodon: “Colony of Birchmen”
Megadeth: “Peace Sells”
Metallica: “Battery”
Mighty Mighty Bosstones: “Where’d You Go”
Modest Mouse: “Float On”
Motorhead: “Ace of Spades”
Nirvana: “Drain You”
Norman Greenbaum: “Spirit in the Sky”
Panic at the Disco: “Nine in the Afternoon”
Paramore: “That’s What You Get”
Pearl Jam: “Alive”
Presidents of the USA: “Lump”
Rage Against the Machine:”Testify”
Ratt: “Round & Round”
Red Hot Chili Peppers : “Give It Away”
Rise Against: “Give It All”
Rush: “The Trees”
Silversun Pickups: “Lazy Eye”
Smashing Pumpkins: “Today”
Social Distortion: “I Was Wrong”
Sonic Youth: “Teen Age Riot”
Soundgarden: “Spoonman”
Squeeze: “Cool for Cats”
Steely Dan: “Bodhitsattva”
Steve Miller Band: “Rock’n Me”
Survivor: “Eye of the Tiger”
System of a Down: “Chop Suey”
Talking Heads: “Psycho Killer”
Tenacious D: “Master Exploder”
Testament: “Souls of Black”
The Donnas: “New Kid in School”
The Go-Go’s: “We Got the Beat”
The Grateful Dead: “Alabama Getaway”
The Guess Who: “American Woman”
The Muffs: “Kids in America”
The Offspring: “Come Out & Play (Keep ‘em Separated)”
The Replacements: “Alex Chilton”
The Who: “Pinball Wizard”
Based on the tone of this rant, I’m sure you can figure out what my opinion of this new installment will be, as this set more or less follows the same formula as the previous game (some current hits, some classic rock, some vintage alternative). I was, however, legitimately surprised by several of the inclusions for this game, such as:
Bikini Kill: “Rebel Girl”
Aside from the fact that this band, who were the poster girls for the riot grrl movement (Sex Pistols meets radical feminism for those of you not familiar) when they were active, were never that popular to begin with, they’re on the Kill Rock Stars label. This was the label that refused to sell a member of Soundgarden a shirt at Lollapalooza because he was in Soundgarden!
Don’t get me wrong, I like this band (I own the album this song was on), but this was the LAST band I was expecting to see.
Lush: “De-Luxe”
In a way, Lush were the most popular shoegazer band in the US. They were, after all, the only band out of the entire movement to have a song played on American radio. However, that particular song was released after the band had more or less abandoned the genre and started aping Britpop bands like Elastica. More to the point though, the song I’m talking about was called “Ladykillers”, not “De-Luxe” (which was released several years beforehand).
I never held out any hopes of seeing any first wave shoegazer music in a videogame like this, and if I did, I would’ve put my money on either My Bloody Valentine (the critical darlings) or Ride (who actually had hit songs).
Sonic Youth: “Teen Age Riot”
I’m not surprised to see SY on here (they were on the previous installment after all). I am surprised, however, to see a song that clocks in a over seven minutes on this list.
The Replacements: “Alex Chilton”
This was one of the inclusions that pleased me the most. For one, it’s a great song by a great band that is, assuming you aren’t a indie snob or a music critic, ridiculously underrated (in spite of the fact that so many ’90s alterna-pop bands ripped off this band mercilessly). Besides the fact that this game is giving exposure to a deserving band that many might not have heard of otherwise, I like how the makers of the game are not simply going for the most popular/obvious song (“Alex Chilton” may have been a great single, but “Bastards of Young” was their most popular, if only for its controversial video/SNL performance), which I guess is why all of the songs I’ve mentioned have surprised me.
So who wants to start a band?